Managing a teamUpdated 7 min read

Is financial advisor coaching worth it? Check your numbers

A coach can help when your production has gone flat and you can't see why. It can also be an expensive monthly call that changes nothing. Here's what a coach does, the signs either way, the questions to ask before you pay, and how to judge it from your own weekly numbers.

What a financial advisor coach does

You're a few years in. You know the products, clients trust you, and your diary isn't empty. But this year looks a lot like last year, and you can't point to why.

That's the moment most advisors start looking at coaching. A financial advisor coach is someone outside your firm who works with you on how you run your practice, usually on a call every week or two. The good ones spend most of that time on four things:

  • Prospecting habits: who you ask for meetings, how often and through which channels.
  • How your week is planned: when calls happen, what gets protected and what gets pushed.
  • Business planning: what the year needs from you, broken into months and weeks.
  • Accountability: someone who asks on Thursday whether you did what you said on Monday.

A coach doesn't do the work for you. They don't book your meetings or write your follow-ups. What they bring is an outside view of your week and a person you'll feel awkward letting down.

Some coaches focus on marketing, some on running a bigger firm, and some on the basics of getting in front of people. Know which of those you need before you start talking to any of them.

A financial coach, an advisor, or a coach for advisors

Search for financial coaching and most of what comes back is a different job: a coach who helps people sort out their own money. Three roles share the words, and they do different work.

RoleWorks onWorks with
Financial coachBudgets, saving, debt and money habitsPeople sorting out their own money
Financial advisorAdvice on financial products and plansClients, through a licensed firm
Coach for advisorsProspecting, your week, your plan, follow-throughAdvisors growing a practice

This post is about the third. Your clients are the ones who buy the first. The second is your job, and in Singapore it comes with a public record: a firm that appoints someone to give financial advice on its behalf has to tell MAS, and that person shows up on the Financial Institution Representatives Register. If a coach you're talking to also recommends products, look them up there. Then ask how they're paid, because a coach who earns on what you buy is selling, not coaching.

Signs coaching would help, and signs it won't

Coaching helps when the gap is in your habits. You already know what to do. The trouble is doing it every single week.

Signs it would help:

  • Your first appointments have dropped and you can't say which week it started.
  • You set a plan in January and stopped looking at it by March.
  • You do your best work when someone is expecting an answer from you.
  • You've got time to act on what comes out of each session.
  • Your manager is stretched across a big team and your 1:1s are short or skipped.

Signs it won't, at least not yet:

  • You're hoping someone will hand you a script that fixes everything. A coach hands you homework, and you still have to do it.
  • You won't track what you do each week. A coach with no numbers is guessing along with you.
  • Your calendar has no room for the changes, so the plan dies on the first busy day.
  • You're really unhappy with the job itself. That's a different conversation, and a coach paid to keep you going isn't the right person to have it with.

If most of the second list is true, start with the self-coaching section below. You can always hire someone later, and you'll get more from them once you know your numbers.

A coach, a course or your manager

A paid coach is one of five places to get this kind of help, and most advisors need two of them at once: something that teaches a skill, and someone who checks the week.

OptionGood forWatch for
Paid coachHabits you know but don't keepA monthly fee and a minimum term
Course or workshopA new skill: referrals, reviews, a new marketNobody checks the week after it ends
Your managerWeekly numbers and a Thursday checkShort or skipped 1:1s on a big team
Peer groupTwo or three advisors comparing numbersIt drifts into chat without numbers
Coaching yourselfThe Friday review further downNobody to let down

A course works when you're missing a skill, like asking for referrals at the end of a review. It doesn't fix a week where the calls never happen, because nobody from the course sees your week. A coach is the opposite: little new teaching, a lot of checking. Before you pay for either, ask for the full cost of the first three months and the notice you need to give to stop.

Red flags, and what to ask before you pay

Most coaching is sold on a free intro call. Go in with questions of your own, so the call isn't only their pitch.

Red flags to watch for:

  • They promise a result in money. Nobody can promise what your clients will decide.
  • They can't say who they don't work with. A coach for everyone is a coach for no one in particular.
  • They talk about mindset for the whole call and never ask about your week.
  • The contract locks you in for a year with no way out after the first few months.
  • They've never sold anything themselves, or they can't explain how they'd help an advisor at your stage.

Questions to ask before you pay:

  1. Who is your coaching built for, and who isn't it for?
  2. What will we work on in the first month, and how will I know if it's moving?
  3. What happens between sessions? Do you check in, or do I just show up to the next call?
  4. Which numbers from my week will you want to see?
  5. How long is the minimum commitment, and how do I stop?
  6. Can I talk to two advisors you've coached at a similar stage?

Question 4 is the one that sorts them. A coach who wants your weekly appointments, meetings held and referral asks is going to work on your habits. A coach who doesn't ask is going to work on how you feel about them.

Ask about credentials too, and know what they cover. The International Coaching Federation runs the best-known ones, and its credentials page sets three levels:

ICF credentialCoach trainingHours coaching clients
ACC60 hours or more100 or more
PCC125 hours or more500 or more
MCC200 hours or more, and a PCC2,500 or more

A credential means the coach was assessed against ICF's core competencies, which ICF groups into four areas: working ethically, agreeing what each session is for, listening well, and turning what you find into actions you're held to. It doesn't tell you whether they understand an advisor's week. Question 4 does.

How to tell if it's working

Judge coaching on whether your week changes, not on how good the calls feel, and measure the change with three numbers you control. Write them down every Friday, and start a month before the first session so you have a baseline to compare against:

  • First appointments booked with new people.
  • Meetings held, new and existing clients.
  • Referrals asked for. Asked, not received, because asking is the part you control.

Made-up example: an advisor, call him Daniel, is four years in. Before coaching, his four-week average was 3 first appointments booked, 9 meetings held and 2 referral asks a week.

His coach spends the first two sessions on one thing: Daniel's calls happen whenever there's a gap, which means most weeks they don't happen. They agree two fixed call blocks, Tuesday and Thursday mornings, and a referral ask at the end of every review meeting.

Weeks one to four: 4, 3, 5, 4 first appointments. Meetings held stay around 9. Referral asks go 5, 6, 4, 7.

Weeks five to eight bring a busy patch of client reviews, Thursday's block gets skipped twice, and first appointments drop back to 3 and 2. At the next call his coach doesn't bring a new idea. She asks what took Thursday, and they move the block to Wednesday, when fewer reviews land.

After eight weeks, Daniel can see the change in his own log, and he can see exactly the week it slipped.

Give it two months. If your three numbers haven't moved by then, raise it on the next call and ask what the coach would change. If nothing changes after that, stop paying, and count the stop as a result too.

Numbers further down the line, like new clients signed, will lag behind. Watch them, but don't expect them to move in the first month.

Coaching only works if you can see your week. In ActivityTracker you log an appointment in one tap, and your goal shows how many you need each month.

See ActivityTracker for advisors

Coaching yourself, or being coached by your manager

You can run most of this without paying anyone. The coach's real job is to keep your week honest, and a few habits cover a lot of it.

Every Friday, take 15 minutes and do this:

  1. Write down this week's three numbers next to last week's.
  2. Pick the one that fell and write one line on why.
  3. Choose a single change for next week, even if you can see five.
  4. Put that change in your calendar before you close the laptop.

A written weekly reflection makes this easier, because you can look back a month and see which changes stuck. The sales accountability guide covers how to make someone else part of it.

If you have a manager, they can be the person who asks on Thursday. Bring the same three numbers to your 1:1 and ask them to check one change with you each week. Most managers would rather coach from real numbers than from a general "how's it going?" If you lead advisors yourself, the same rule works the other way. Ask for the three numbers before the 1:1, and spend the meeting on the one that fell. Coaching software can keep each session's notes on the advisor's page, so the next 1:1 starts where the last one ended.

An advisor's coaching page: points this week, the weekly trend, dated notes from past 1:1s and a Prep me button
One advisor's coaching page in ActivityTracker: points against the weekly goal, an eight-week trend and notes from past 1:1s.

If you're still in your first couple of years, the first-year financial advisor guide covers the habits worth building before any of this.

Keep reading

Questions people ask

Sources

Know your week first.

Then decide who helps you with it.